I’ll be honest, this story infuriated me when I read it tonight.

Another high school football coach loses his job while trying to teach kids to commit to something.

Read the whole story here.

See a CBS news segment here.

I’ll summarize it:

1.  Kid tells Head Coach he will miss a varsity football game because he has a baseball “showcase” out of state.

2.  Coach says if you go, don’t come back, you will be removed from team for missing that game.

3.  11 other kids quit in support of the player.

4.  Principal fires the coach.

5.  All 12 kids are reinstated to team.

Coach Mahaffey Photo Credit Victor Calderon

What are we teaching our kids these days administrators?  What value in teamwork and commitment are we teaching them if we allow the kids to call the shots?   That is what happened here.  

The kids called the shots.

The principal said that: “Based on the fact that there weren’t any rules, guidelines or expectations given to the players in a written format that they had signed off on, I felt like I didn’t have anything that could support the decision he made.”

There are two sides to this coin.  I agree with putting something in writing for everyone at the beginning of the season.  This might clear up a lot of issues for you, and put all of the expectations on the table.  Having a written policy on the discipline is always a great idea.  I have a bunch of those forms in my Outside The Lines Manual.  But even if there was a written contract, would the kid not have gone to the showcase? I doubt it.

Principal Ginter: here is what I don’t understand sir, with all due respect:

In your school’s very own Athletic Code of Conduct, it clearly states that:

Failure to Participate
If a student/athlete fails to participate without justifiable cause or drops out of a
sport after the teams first league contest, the student/athlete will not be allowed to
participate in any other sport until the season of the dropped sport is completed.

Missing scheduled practices, performances, or games without approved medical
reasons, or having made prior arrangements with the person in charge may be
grounds for dismissal from the team. Each school will have its own policy on
attending practice sessions.

Student Athlete Code of Conduct

2. To acknowledge that participation on an athletic team is a privilege, not a right and
as such is subject to the rules and regulations of Rio Americano High School, the
California Interscholastic Federation, the San Juan Unified School District and the
San Juan Unified School District Athletic Department. Student athletes are under
the direction of the administration, the athletic director, the head varsity coach and
the assistant coaches.

Principal Ginter: wasn’t Coach Mahaffey justified to remove this student-athlete from the football program because of the general school athletic policies put in to place, and signed by this student-athlete and parents?  You said that there “weren’t any rules, guidelines, or expectations;” but there were.  I found them myself with a simple Google search of your school’s athletic department.

I’m very curious, as an Athletic Director and 13 year football coach to know why these school policies weren’t applied in this case.  Why was a coach fired for following school policy sir?

This happened to me before, in 2009, with the SAME EXACT baseball “showcase.”

 I had two kids tell me they had to go to this same baseball “showcase” that this kid went to.  

They went.  I suspended them an entire game when they came back.  One of the kids didn’t like that so he quit.  A starting running back. I let him go.  Where is that kid today?  Let me tell you this, he certainly didn’t get the “promised scholarship” from that “showcase!”  He quit school during his senior year, didn’t even play baseball his senior year, he quit that too.

Folks, that’s what we get when we let kids call the shots!  We teach them it’s okay to call the shots, what do they learn?  (I’m getting fired up again just thinking about all of that I dealt with in 2009!)  That kid that missed our varsity football game, then quit football altogether never learned anything from his “all star baseball” coaches growing up because he was always the star of the team.  And he was treated differently.  He was allowed to break the rules, to bend the rules and to stretch the rules.  Was I around to see this happen?  No.  How do I know?  Because of how he acted in my football program.  And by how he ended up quitting the varsity baseball team when things didn’t go his way!

I don’t know this head football coach Christian Mahaffey, I’ve never met the guy.  But if I ever did, I would say “Coach, great job sticking to your guns and teaching these kids life skills beyond the football field.  I’m sorry that principal through you and your entire program right under the bus.”

You see, now that entire program (in my opinion) has just lost years of discipline and commitment by this one act of the principal.  I would hate to be the next coach.  You have ZERO pull now with the kids.  If they think you are running them too hard one day, they will run to the principal.  If they think you are not calling the right plays, they might run to the principal.  If you yell at Johnny because he isn’t trying, the whole team might quit, walk to the principal’s office and get the new guy fired!

Coach Mahaffey, so the principal suspended the kids for one game for walking away from the team. Was this in writing?  He said your discipline wasn’t in writing so he couldn’t support you.  Was it in writing somewhere that “If you and 10 other teammates quit your team in support of another player who quit the team, then get reinstated, you will serve a one game suspension.”  I want to see that in writing.

Coach Mahaffey, this is a tough time to be in the coaching profession.  In so many ways, our hands are tied by the politics in our communities and by administrators who are more concerned with making parents and kids happy than teaching them life lessons.

Coach Mahaffey, I admire that you stood by your policy and had the backbone to stand up for the right thing.

Coach Mahaffey, can you imagine missing one of your varsity football games for an out of season “showcase?!”  Of course not!

Coach Mahaffey, I wonder how those other 22 boys feel?  The ones who didn’t quit.  What has your principal taught those kids?

Coach Mahaffey, I feel bad for you.

Coach Mahaffey, you did the right thing.

Coach Mahaffey, good luck finding a new coaching gig.  I know you might be too sour on it to try to find another gig when a school you’ve been at for so long throws you under the bus.  Hang in there.

Coach Mahaffey, I’m an Athletic Director, and I will use this story for a long time.  I will use it to teach my coaches to have written guidelines up front for parents.  I will use it to communicate to athletes how important commitment to the team is.  I will use it to talk with administrators about policies and procedures to make sure we don’t allow this to happen on my watch.

Coach Mahaffey, good luck to you in the future.

– Coach Fore   @coachfore on twitter


  1. Excellent post, coach.

    I had a similar thing happen to me a few years ago, although it wasn’t about out of season sports stuff. I had just taken over the program and were working on building a disciplined program that had previously lacked it. In our doing so, we were told we were being too harsh on players, because (among other things) we didn’t let them have their last names on their jerseys, sat players for discipline issues, and the “helmets on at all times when on the field” rule. It was even suggested by the District HR administrator that I cancel the coming Tuesday night practice and go out for pizza! After the third game, an administrator was assigned to be at every practice, which effectively killed any chance of being able to teach the kids anything from that point forward. I resigned as soon as the year was over

    • Thanks for sharing that story Troy. I’ve seen some admin do some pretty ridiculous stuff. For many of them, athletics really is nothing more than guitar class or math class. They don’t understand the dedication and determination that makes athletics what it is.
      I’m glad you resigned, doesn’t seem like a good place to be.

  2. I am a baseball coach. In the Spring, the FBLA state conference runs during baseball season. I had a starter decide he was going to this 2 day conference. He was going to miss 2 practices and a conference game. He asked me if he could go. Our school policy stated that I could not punish an athlete for attending school related event. I didn’t punish him, but since he missed practice and a game, another athlete had to take his place. The athlete who missed had a dad that happened to be an adminstrator in the district. He asked me if I would suspend his kid for missing. I told him no, but that he lost his starting position because he missed. It wasn’t a punishment, it was just that I had to play someone else there, and that kid did pretty well, so I couldn’t justify putting that other kid back on the bench so that starter could play. The first athlete ended up sitting out 3 more games because he couldn’t work his way back into the lineup. His dad confronted me several times about it and mentioned subtly to start his kid. His son made his way back into the lineup do to an injury by another starter, but I did not back down. I am not longer at the school because things became EXTREMELY difficult for me after that. Everywhere you go, the kids call the shots because parents run the school districts, not the people trained to do it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s